After only six seasons with the Kansas City Chiefs, Patrick Mahomes has established himself as arguably the best quarterback in the NFL. The phenom quarterback clearly has a bright future ahead of him.
It’s no wonder his trading cards are in such high demand and that collectors are willing to break the bank to own the best Patrick Mahomes football cards.
Most Expensive Patrick Mahomes Football Card
The most expensive Patrick Mahomes football card ever sold is the 2017 NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes Rookie Auto card. PWCC Marketplace sold this card for $4.3 million in an auction, making it the most expensive football card ever sold.
Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card
The same card mentioned above is also considered the most expensive rookie card for Mahomes. The 2017 NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes Rookie Auto card is currently the most expensive rookie card for Mahomes. A card shop in New Albany, OH, spent $4.3 million to get this one-of-a-kind card.
12 Most Expensive Patrick Mahomes Football Cards
12. 2016 Select ’17 Rookie Patrick Mahomes Gold Prizms
Price: $193,000
This limited-edition card fetched an impressive $193,000 in an auction. With only eight cards in circulation, this rookie card is a highly collectible item.
The card features yellow borders contrasting against a dark background. It uses a photograph of Patrick Mahomes in his Kansas City Chiefs uniform about to throw a pass. The back of the card discusses his impressive throw ability and refers to an 80-yard pass the quarterback completed during his first season with the Chiefs.
This card from 2016 is an interesting addition to any NFL collection since it’s the year Mahomes joined the Chiefs and became the franchise’s most valuable rookie.
11. 2017 National Treasures Colossal Patrick Mahomes RC NFL Shield Auto
Price: $288,000
Sales records from PWCC MarketPlace show that this card sold for $288,000. It’s an elusive card with only one copy ever made. This Treasures Colossal card from Panini is part of a series with 19 cards, including two autographed cards.
The card's crisp design creates an aesthetic result with the Chiefs’ red and white uniform. The card uses a white background with red stripes at the top and bottom. There is a Rookie Colossal logo at the top, a prominent NFL logo on the left, and a photograph of Patrick Mahomes on the right. You can find his signature at the bottom of the card design.
10. 2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes NFL Shield RPA
Price: $312,000
Panini delivers high-end football cards with its flawless collection. These cards originally came with a metal briefcase and additional memorabilia.
The card stands out thanks to the landscape orientation of its design. You’ll find a large NFL logo on the left and a full-body picture of Patrick Mahomes on the right. There is a brief biography of the quarterback on the back of the card underneath a Kansas City logo.
This rookie card reached $312,000 in a private auction.
9. 2017 Panini Contenders Cracked Ice Patrick Mahomes Rookie Auto
Price: $336,000
Another card selling for six figures, the 2017 Panini Contenders Cracked Ice Patrick Mahomes Rookie Auto card is one of the most valuable Mahomes rookie cards.
It’s the most valuable and popular card out of the Panini Contenders series for that year. There is a lot of interest from collectors with 13 recent auction records for this card. On average, this card goes for five figures, but one specimen reached $336,000 in a private auction.
There are two variants of the card. One uses a landscape format while the other uses a portrait orientation. Both cards feature a rookie ticket with the QB’s name, team logo, and Panini logo. You’ll also find a crisp photograph of Patrick Mahomes and his signature.
There is a slight difference between the two variants. They use the same photograph, but the portrait version features a full body shot while the landscape card crops the photograph at the waist.
8. 2017 National Treasures Green Patrick Mahomes RPA
Price: $360,000
A 2017 National Treasures Patrick Mahomes card recently sold for a record-breaking $4.3 million. This card is part of the same series and reached $360,000 in an auction.
The National Treasures series includes different color-coded variants. The Green variant features green borders against a white background. The card encloses a patch from a uniform worn by Patrick Mahomes, and you’ll also find a photograph of the player and his signature. The design is classic, but the uniform patch turns it into an exceptional piece of memorabilia.
There seems to be an active market for this card, with several recent auction records from PWCC MarketPlace and other auction houses advertising the lot on YouTube.
7. 2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes RPA (#53/99) – PSA 10
Price: $399,750
According to auction records from Goldin Auctions, a collector purchased this rookie card for $399,750 in October 2021. The seller originally bought the card on eBay for a little under $4,000.
This National Treasures NFL card is one of the best Mahomes rookie cards. It has a flawless grading, and it’s one of eight graded cards in existence. Prices range from $20,000 to $50,000 for lower grades.
The uniform patch adds value since it features straight lines with white, yellow, and red colors that feel emblematic of the Chiefs’ uniform. The straight lines complement the crisp design of the card and create an aesthetic result.
The card uses a photograph of Mahomes about to complete a throw. It’s a simple design, but the card puts the photograph, signature, and uniform patch forward.
6. 2017 National Treasures Red NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes Rookie Patch Auto
Price: $456,000
This National Treasures card reached $456,000 in a private auction. This 2017 rookie card features a uniform patch next to a photograph of Patrick Mahomes ready to throw. You’ll also find the player’s signature.
The design features white and red elements that complement the colors of the uniform patch. The red variant of this card features a mostly red uniform patch, making it emblematic of the team’s uniform. It’s a great piece of memorabilia to celebrate Patrick Mahomes’ exceptional rookie year with the Chiefs.
5. 2017 Panini Prizm Gold Vinyl Prizm Rookie Card – PSA 10
Price: $676,000
Collectors often seek rookie cards of a player who made it big. Patrick Mahomes is no exception, with yet another rookie card fetching six figures in an auction.
This card uses a vintage-inspired design and stands out thanks to the shimmer that characterizes the Prizm collection. There is a photograph of Patrick Mahomes running and ready to throw a pass against a green background. The gold borders create an aesthetic contrast and emphasize the shimmer.
This emblematic rookie card sold for $676,500 in an auction from Goldin Auctions. A total of 12 collectors bid on this lot. Another card from the same series sold for $570,000 after receiving three bids.
There are only five Prizm Gold cards with perfect grading in existence. Given that these cards don’t feature an autograph, it’s unusual to see six-figure prices.
4. 2017 Panini National Treasures “Stars & Stripes Patch Auto”
Price: $720,000
The “Stars & Stripes Patch Auto” is a unique take on the National Treasures series. This rookie card features a stars and stripes design that frames the uniform patch embedded in the card. The uniform patch makes the card highly collectible since it features a portion of the team’s logo.
Originally listed for sale in January 2022, a 2017 Panini National Treasures “Stars & Stripes Patch Auto” card reached the impressive sum of $720,000. At the time of the auction, this specimen was the only card in existence with a grading of 10 for this series.
3. 2017 Panini National Treasures Black Patrick Mahomes RPA
Price: $840,000
This card is one of the most valuable rookie cards ever for the NFL. It sold for $840,000 after receiving 39 bids in an auction from Goldin Auctions. The selling price far exceeded the $50,000 minimum bid for this card.
The black variant of the National Treasures series uses black design elements to frame the card’s design. You’ll find a photograph of Patrick Mahomes in action, his signature, and a uniform patch. This record-breaking card featured a uniform patch with part of the bottom right corner of the Kansas City Chiefs’ logo visible.
It also had the first serial number in a series with only five cards, contributing to the high selling price.
At the time of the auction in January 2021, this sale represented the most anyone had ever spent for a Patrick Mahomes card. It’s an impressive record considering that the card had a grading of 9/10.
2. 2017 National Treasures Holo Gold Patrick Mahomes RPA
Price: $1.1 Million
This rookie card from the National Treasures collection broke records with a $1.1 million sale. The card had a grading of 9.5 and features serial number 3 in a series with only ten cards.
The gold variant of the National Treasures design features a gold framing for the uniform patch and for the elements visible behind Patrick Mahomes’ head. Gold and holographic
The patch makes the card stand out because it features a portion of the Kansas City logo with some stars visible. It makes the logo highly recognizable, and combined with the excellent grading of the card,it turns it into a highly collectible item.
Auction houses have listed other cards from the Holo Gold series, but none of these sales reached the million-dollar mark.
1. 2017 NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes Rookie Auto
Price: $4.3 Million
In July 2021, PWCC MarketPlace made history by selling the most expensive NFL card ever. The 2017 NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes Rookie Auto card reached a staggering $4.3 million in an auction. This exceptional sale confirms that Patrick Mahomes rookie cards are a hot item for collectors.
While football cards have not traditionally held the same value as rare vintage baseball cards, this Mahomes rookie card found a place on the list of most expensive sports cards ever sold.
There is only one of these cards in existence. Despite an 8.5 grading, this card stands out thanks to its near-mint condition and pristine autograph. The uniform patch also makes the card extremely valuable since it features the NFL logo. The centering of the logo is perfect, and the card design uses blue borders to complement the logo on the patch.
This record-breaking sale represents the most expensive NFL card ever. It broke a previous record held by a Tom Brady card that sold for $3.1 million.
Conclusion
With a $4.3 million sale, Patrick Mahomes’ rookie cards will likely remain popular and valuable for the years to come. Future cards will likely not be as valuable as his rookie cards, but some of his most popular rookie cards might fetch higher prices as collectors decide to resell them.
Patrick Mahomes recently became the fastest quarterback to reach 20,000 passing yards. With a promising career ahead of him, collectors will keep seeking his rookie cards and other pieces of memorabilia.
